After leaving her Amish town and the only family she has ever known, Katie Lapp ventures to New York City to find her birth mother, Laura Mayfield-Bennett. Katie finds Laura but is shocked to discover an imposter claiming to be Katie Lapp is already living in Laura's home. As Katie tries to unravel the mystery, Daniel Fisher, the young man who captured Katie's heart years ago, has returned to find Katie—the one woman he ever truly loved.