On Halloween morning in the small town of Hagerstown, Maryland, the body of a father is discovered in a pool of blood. Police attention turns to the victim's daughter, her Goth friends, and a tragic misunderstanding that destroys three lives. A 31-year-old wife and mother openly engages in an affair with a teenage lover. When her husband is found shot dead in the doorway of their home, police must sort through a tangled web of lies and manipulation to get to the truth.