A cash-strapped Nicky pushes his luck by trying to open a new psychic shop in South Beach, Florida, causing friction with rival Romani, as well as his wife Christine. Bobby struggles with single life on a night out with his brother Jack. Back in New York, the brothers get news that their father Bob has suffered from a stroke and needs emergency surgery. When the issue of consent divides the family, a fight breaks out between Nicky and Bobby, leaving their father's life hanging in the balance.