Pastor David "Brother" Love presides over a close-knit church in a community outside of Kansas City in 2000. The parishioners admire him, maybe none more so than Randy Stone, a loyal church member and one of his closest friends. But loyalties are tested when Love becomes too close with Randy's wife, Teresa. The forbidden relationship leads to a decade-long affair full of secrets and lies. Manipulation, jealous, money and heartbreak all play a part in this chilling story that leads to a shocking investigation of murder.