After a frustrating house hunt, new parents Allison and Robert thought they lucked out on finding a quaint 1200 square foot home in a prestigious neighborhood. But after moving in, Allison saw their house in a whole new, negative light. She thinks their only solution for more space, more storage, and an upstairs bathroom is to move. But Robert is content with their home and wants to stay put. Wedging themselves into this debate are Realtor David and Designer Hilary. David hopes to find this couple a home with more space and function while Hilary and her team try to completely re-imagine this couple's small house. Desperate for a home with more room, Robert and Allison will have to decide if they can love their home again? Or will they list it?