Bartholomew, an insecure, by-the-book perfectionist, is tasked with welcoming the recently deceased to heaven's waiting room. Peter, his first death, challenges him to face his fears, doubts and insecurities, with the hope that Bartholomew will send Peter back to the living. Will Bartholomew see the light? Or will Peter be forced to live the rest of eternity facing his regrets and unfulfilled potential?